Supreme Pizza in Waterford

Love this place Great food nice people what more could you want

Been going there for over 20 years, it's great food

Family owned for many year. Great food

You can always count on great food and great service!

I have always loved supreme pizza. Aside from the food being awesome every time I have been over the last 15 years, the employees are always extremely friendly, clean and attentive, even when they are very busy I always am greeted within seconds of walking in the door. If you have never been I would definitely recommend trying them out! P.S. my personal favorite thing to order is the tuna fish grinder... absolutely the best around😁

Used to come here all the time when I was a kid with my Mom. It's still quality food and friendly service. Highly recommend if you're craving a grinder.

Best pizza excellent service...

This is my favorite pizza place. I've never had anything here I didn't love, and the service is excellent. Everybody's always joking with each other and laughing, and I always leave feeling happier. And the salads are incredible.

Excellent food! Nice little hole in the wall with great grinder and pizza options. My mother-in-law got a grilled chicken salad which was huge and tasty. I got a spicy Italian grinder (only half of it pictured because I was so hungry) and my wife got a pepperoni grinder. Both were delicious and big for a size small. The staff was really friendly too. I would highly recommend!

The pizza and grinders are awesome. And the homemade chicken soup is really yummy. Mmmmm

Used to come here growing up. Still just as good as it was back then. Had the BEST sausage grinder- peppers & onions and homemade sauce. Perfectly cooked. Other half had a meatball grinder. Just as delicious. Very impressed. Will be coming back more frequently.

A slice or a whole a delicious pizza at a reasonable price

We love the food and travel from 2 towns over for take out. The owners and staff are friendly and do a great job. The restaraunt is always busy but the wait is always short. A side note: The darkside of google reivews ala "Rachel and James Smith". Troll accounts used to unfairly slander a business. "Ms. Smith", a 300# karen type, was last seen having her payment repeately declined, causing a huge delay for the other customers waiting. After several declines the owner moved on to the other waiting customers - causing "Karen" to have a major entitled white girl meltdown, screaming profanities at the waiting customers. Apparently she isn't done and is now atttempting to damage a beloved neighborhood business, through no fault of their own. Supreme Pizza has a 5 star rating for good reason - give them a try, you won't be disappointed.

This is a family owned business that has been in business a great many years. They have been serving Waterford, New London and many of the surrounding locations for over 25 years with great food, outstanding customer service and, always a good laugh or two. Eat in or take out, you will get a lot of bang for your buck here. This pizza/grinder shop cooks fresh and to perfection and if you go in hungry, you for sure will not leave there hungry because, when your here, your family. My family and I have been eating here for at least, 20 years.

Very good pizza.

Everyone is always friendly when I go in, the owners remember my name and always stop to make conversation with me. The food is ALWAYS amazing!! Best grinders and pasta around. Hands down my favorite place in town to eat :) Thank you to everyone at Supreme for providing nothing but the absolute best service with quality food to match.

Love, love there food & service!!

Fabulous prices.Amazing Owner!!! So friendly EVERY TIME you go!! THE BEST GRINDERS IN WATERFORD HANDS DOWN!!!!! They have never got an order wrong and everything is fresh and perfect every time! Thank you for the amazing service and even better food ❤️

Had a meatball grinder and it was amazing. Everyone was super friendly here as well :)

From start to finish the best restaurant in Waterford! Everything is always fresh, staff are so kind and attentive. Great food, only grinders I order for my family!

I love Supreme Pizza, I've been going here since I was a little kid. I have since moved away, and anytime I come back getting Supreme Pizza is always one of my favorite things to do. They also always remember me when I go in which blows my mind.

this is the place to go, nuff' said.

Great pizza and friendly staff I like to stop in to get slices on my way to work sometimes

Always great food, great service, extra fast, extra clean and love the fact that “Everybody knows your name!” They have the COVID Pandemic drills covered. Gives you peace of mind to eat their food.

Love this place! Been going for years now. Family owned and the staff are always friendly. Food is great and portions are large!

Always great! I recommend the special pizza.

Luv this place..everything they make is delicious.

There was hair in my pizza. It was really chewy. Unfortunately I won't be going going back there again.

Not what it used to be. They take the phone off the hook all the time when you try to call to place an order. The food is no where near what it was before the kids took over.

Excellent food and service. The staff there is great.

I haven't been here in years... and decided to go today because every other pizza shop in new london was closed... but let me tell u... the hospitality... the welcoming feeling... n the friendliest, greatest smiles, makes this my new favorite pizza place!!! Not to mention the food was delicious!.... thank u Supreme Pizza....

Wonderful food and fantastic staff. The owners know most tof their cutomers by name and treat them like friends coming to visit. The model of what a great neighborhood place should be.

Came in a little before they closed to order a pizza for takeout. They took care of me, were very polite, and made me a delicious pizza. I would absolutely order from here again. Loved it!

Love this place. ..always great to see Nick, Tim and the great crew!! Food is always delicious.

The Absolute Best Tuna Grinders in the Area.. Yummmm.

I've been eating here for years and just never thought to comment. I love the place and the food, staff is super friendly. It is one of the best places in this area and always a good experience.

Great pizza and friendly staff

The only place to go to buy a sub yummy

Pizza was ok. The crust had too much oil on crust. I prefer more sauce. The prices I thought were on the high side .

Good people work here.You will be remembered. All that and best food in the area. That's why I keep going back.

Awesome pizza that’s a good size, and good price. Best meatball subs around. And the best staff ever! Always feel like family, they seem to know everyone’s name after you’ve been once or twice. It’s amazing and it’s a great environment.

Great pizza and Grinders are better than all the rest

Some of the people are friendly, theres one person that is rude, (forgot the name). During the start if the Covid-19, they took my credit card and washed it with soap and water, they didn't tell or ask me. I also think that the food is ok, yet a little expensive for the quality and quantity.

Came in for a simple lunch. Left with a full stomach. Best $10 I've spent for lunch. A family owned and operated place. Friendly. The owners know the customer by first name. They greet everyone. They make custom meal orders. I will return.

Great service. Great food. Haven't found another place quite like it anywhere I travel. They care about the food they serve and their customers!

Fantastic family-owned and run restaurant. Excellent food!

Supreme Pizza really is Supreme! Forget about the chain pizza factories. These folks have been serving Waterford and New London County from before the chains arrived. The chains advertise low prices but have gimmicks that wind up costing you.Supreme Pizza has great pizzas, sheet pizzas for parties, pastas, salads and the best loaded grinders.Support your local businesses.Try Supreme Pizza, you will become a loyal member of their family.The owners are always on the premises making sure you are satisfied!

Meatball grinder is so good. The bread is perfect. Owners are friendly and somehow remember everyone's name. Good food, good spot for family or friends

One of our favorite places. Very generous portions for any meal or salad, good pizza, great staff.

The menu and service were ahead of our expectations. We absolutely liked the atmosphere of this spot. Extraordinary spot to take my family out for dinner.